Why Your Closet Is Full but Your Outfits Still Don’t Work

Written by Brandi Hearn

There are plenty of clothes in your closet. Enough that the hangers barely move. And yet, when you need to get dressed for dinner, you somehow end up trying on the same three things.

One shirt goes back on the hanger. The jacket gets left on the bed. You change your shoes twice and leave wearing something you've worn many times before.

It's frustrating, especially when you've spent good money on what's hanging there.

When I look at a wardrobe like this, I want to understand what happens between buying the clothes and actually wearing them. Usually, there are a few reasons the options feel so limited.

You Keep Buying Something You Already Have

Another blue shirt can look like a perfectly reasonable purchase. You like blue. You wear shirts. This one has a slightly different collar.

But once it's home, it may do exactly what the other six do. Meanwhile, you still don't have a shirt you like wearing out to dinner.

The same thing happens with sneakers, jeans, and navy jackets. It's easy to buy more of the category you feel comfortable choosing. The less familiar part of your wardrobe keeps waiting.

I'd look at what the new piece lets you wear. If it gives you another version of an outfit you already have, it may be less useful than the shoes that would help you wear three neglected pairs of trousers.

You Like the Pieces, but Haven't Figured Out the Outfits

Say you bought a jacket you loved in the store. At home, you tried it with your usual chinos, and it looked a little too formal. You put it aside until you found better trousers.

Then you bought the trousers, but your shoes didn't look right with them.

Now you own two good pieces that still aren't getting worn.

This is why I think about the surrounding wardrobe when I select something. I want to know what shirt goes underneath the jacket, how the trousers sit over the shoes, and where you'd actually wear the combination.

It's much easier to reach for an outfit when you've already seen it work.

Something About the Fit Bothers You

You might say that you just prefer your old trousers. Put on the newer pair, sit down, and suddenly there's a more specific explanation. They're tight through the thigh.

Or the shirt you never wear feels fine until you button the collar. The jacket looks good open but pulls when you fasten it.

After a while, you stop trying those pieces. You don't necessarily think through the reason each morning. You just know you'd rather wear something else.

I wouldn't take that as proof that tailored trousers or button-down shirts aren't for you. I'd want to see whether a different cut, fabric, or alteration would make them more comfortable. Your favorites can tell us quite a bit about what works. I go into that in Why You Keep Wearing the Same Five Outfits.

Much of Your Closet Belongs to a Different Part of Your Life

Maybe you used to wear a suit four days a week. Now you work from home and meet clients a few times a month. You still have all the suits, but very little you like wearing on an ordinary day.

Or you've accumulated clothes for weddings, vacations, and the occasional formal event while barely paying attention to what you wear every weekend.

You can see how the closet fills up. What it contains and what you need most often have gradually moved apart.

Some of those occasion pieces may be worth keeping. I'd simply give more attention to the part of your wardrobe you're asking to do the most work now.

The Good Options Are Waiting to Be Finished

The trousers need hemming. The jacket has been waiting for a sleeve adjustment since you bought it. Your second pair of loafers needs a repair.

Each one feels like a small errand, so it gets put off. Meanwhile, you're getting dressed from the few things that are ready.

Before you go shopping again, see what would become available if you finished those jobs. Sometimes there's quite a useful wardrobe sitting in the alterations pile.

Find Out What's Happening in Your Closet

You may recognize more than one of these patterns. That's fine. Start with the one that causes the most frustration when you're getting dressed.

Perhaps you need to try a few complete outfits. Perhaps you need to stop buying shirts for a while and look at your shoes. Or perhaps it's finally time to book that tailoring appointment.

For a more thorough review, the step-by-step wardrobe audit will help you work through what you own.

You should be able to open your closet and find a few things you're looking forward to wearing. It helps to understand what's getting in the way.

BRANDI HEARN

Strategic Wardrobe Advisor · Los Angeles

Brandi Hearn is a Strategic Wardrobe Advisor with more than a decade of experience helping accomplished men build intentional wardrobes around their careers, lifestyles, and how they want to show up.

Private Wardrobe Advisory →

Previous
Previous

The Curarte Neutrals Map: The Starting Point for a Sharper Wardrobe

Next
Next

The Subtle Mistakes Keeping You From Looking Put Together